In organizational life, the metaphor of the “square peg in a round hole” is often used to describe a team member who is fundamentally mismatched for their role or environment. But what about the octagonal peg in a round hole-someone who almost fits, but not quite? This subtle distinction captures a scenario where a team member’s skills, personality, or working style closely align with the group, yet some edges remain, preventing true cohesion.
Understanding the Octagonal Peg
Unlike the square peg, the octagonal peg nearly fits the round hole. With only minor misalignments, this person can perform their role, contribute meaningfully, and even thrive in certain aspects. However, these small differences-be they communication styles, values, or work habits-create friction points that can hinder full integration into the team’s culture or workflow[1][2].
This “almost but not quite” fit is often more challenging than an obvious mismatch. The team may sense something is off but struggle to articulate or address it. The result is a lingering lack of cohesion, where collaboration feels slightly forced, and the group never quite achieves optimal synergy.
Impacts on Team Cohesion
Cohesion in teams relies on shared goals, trust, clear communication, and complementary strengths[3]. When an octagonal peg is present, several issues can arise:
· Subtle Miscommunication: Minor differences in interpretation or approach can lead to recurring misunderstandings.
· Role Ambiguity: The near-fit team member may struggle with expectations, unsure of how to fully contribute or where their boundaries lie[3].
· Reduced Trust: Even small disconnects can erode trust, as team members may question the commitment or reliability of the outlier.
· Stalled Collaboration: The group may hesitate to fully engage, sensing that consensus is harder to reach or that the dynamic is slightly off-kilter.
These issues rarely escalate to open conflict but can quietly undermine morale and productivity over time.
Why Near-Fits Are Tricky
The challenge with the octagonal peg is that their differences are not glaring enough to warrant immediate intervention. Managers may hesitate to address the issue, hoping it will resolve itself. The team member, meanwhile, may feel the pressure to conform, leading to frustration or disengagement[2][4].
In larger organizations, there may be opportunities to realign roles or teams to better accommodate individual strengths. In smaller teams, however, flexibility is limited, and the near-fit dynamic can persist, slowly eroding cohesion[2].
Strategies for Leaders
To address the octagonal peg scenario, leaders should:
· Foster Open Communication: Encourage honest dialogue about team dynamics and individual experiences. This can surface subtle issues before they become entrenched[3].
· Clarify Roles and Expectations: Ensure everyone understands their responsibilities and how they contribute to team goals[3].
· Leverage Strengths: Identify and utilize the unique strengths of each team member, even if they don’t perfectly match the original role[4].
· Promote Flexibility: Where possible, adapt roles or workflows to better fit individual capabilities, rather than forcing conformity[2][4].
· Build Trust: Invest in team-building and trust-building activities to bridge minor gaps and reinforce a sense of belonging[3].
Conclusion
The octagonal peg in a round hole is a nuanced metaphor for the near-fit team member-someone who almost, but not quite, integrates with the group. Recognizing and addressing this dynamic is crucial for leaders seeking to foster true cohesion. By embracing flexibility and focusing on strengths, teams can transform near-fits into valued contributors, unlocking greater collaboration and success.
1. https://blogs.ams.org/matheducation/2020/04/14/square-peg-in-an-octagonal-hole/
2. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/square-peg-employee-doesnt-fit-round-hole-role-how-doug
3. https://proactsafety.com/blog-posts/what-destroys-team-cohesion
4. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/square-peg-hole-empowering-your-team-harnessing-strengths-manley